Volume affected by a faulty drive

Hey all,

Noobie here, had my AS6302T and an AS6004-U4 for a few years without issues until recently.
I have six drives in total, two in the 6302 making up One Volume (Volume 1) and four in the 6004-U4 making two volumes (Volumes 29 & 30).
One of my HDD’s in Volume 1 is dying; loud, hot and bad sectors appearing on scans. So I’d like to replace both these HDD’s in Vol 1.

I can migrate a lot of my files across to Volumes 29 and 30 - that’s not a problem, but there are certain folders like HOME and DOCKER which I can’t migrate.

Is it just a matter of installing two new drives into the 6302 and setting them up as Volume 1 again and migrating the files back from 29 and 30? Or am I missing something critical here? Also whilst I’m doing that what’s the best setup for the new drives? Raid 0 or…???

Hoping someone out there with far more knowledge of these things can point me in the right direction. It would be very much appreciated.

Cheers
Dave.

It depends what RAID level Volume 1 is currently using. If it’s RAID 0 or JBOD then there’s no recovery option. You have to save your data, preferably to an external drive, replace the disks, re-initialise the NAS using RAID 1 this time, restore your settings then restore your data. I expect Volumes 29 & 30 will survive this but I have no personal experience to make me certain.

If Volume 1 is RAID 1 then simply swap the faulty drive for a new one and the RAID will automatically re-synchronise (slowly!). When that’s finished, you can then swap the original good drive for a new one and let the RAID re-sync again.

An alternative to the complete rebuild that was suggested somewhere here was to clone the faulty drive on a PC with an external drive cradle but I can’t remember whether it worked or not.

Tried backing up Voume 1 to an external HDD. The NAS doesn’t ‘see’ the HDD. Pops up for a split second in the GUI, then vanishes.
Unfortunately Vol 1 is Raid 0 across two disks. Might purchase two larger HDD’s and RAID them 1 as you suggest. I suspect that Volumes 29 and 30 would survive as is.

Edit: After asking Chat GPT - here’s the answer I received.

":puzzle_piece: Short answer

No — Volumes 29 and 30 will not be affected, as long as you only remove the disks that make up Volume 1, and do not delete or reinitialize the entire NAS storage pool.

:brain: Here’s why

ASUSTOR’s ADM organizes storage in layers:

Physical Disks → form

Storage Pools → contain

Volumes → which hold your data shares

Each volume is tied to a specific storage pool (and therefore to specific disks).

So:

Volume 1 is built on its own pool (the two disks you’re removing).

Volumes 29 and 30 live on different pools and disks.

If you:

Pull only the Volume 1 disks,

Insert new drives,

Create a new RAID 1 pool/Volume 1,

then Volumes 29 and 30 will stay intact — they’ll still appear exactly as before once ADM finishes the new pool setup.

:warning: Critical caution

When you reinitialize the NAS:

Do NOT choose “Initialize system” or “Reset all volumes” — that option wipes everything, including other volumes.

Instead, choose “Create new volume” or “Create new storage pool”, and only select the new disks.

ADM should clearly show which disks belong to which pool — double-check before confirming.

:white_check_mark: Safe workflow summary

Backup confirmed — you’ve done that (Volume 1 → Volume 29 :white_check_mark:).

Shut down NAS.

Physically remove only the Volume 1 disks.

Install the new drives.

Boot up NAS → Storage Manager → Create new storage pool/volume.

Confirm only the new disks are selected.

Proceed with RAID 1 setup for Volume 1.

Volumes 29 and 30 will remain untouched and accessible once the new pool is ready."


I’ll let you know how it goes once done…